Dear Readers, Your Review Matters!

love of books

Out of every 100 copies of my book sold, approximately 2 people will leave a review.  The fact is that most readers don’t think it’s important to leave a review and wouldn’t even consider that their opinion might improve the book’s visibility on Amazon or Goodreads.  In fact, few people outside of the publishing industry are aware of the importance of reviews.  They are the lifeblood of authors and their books – a priceless promotional tool that is aimed purely at other readers.

The publishing industry has changed a lot.  It used to be that you went to your local bookshop, picked up a book you liked the look of and if you enjoyed it, you probably loaned it to a couple of friends.  There was no such thing as writing a review and word of mouth was the only way to spread the love.  Nowadays however, leaving travel reviews on sites such as TripAdvisor has become the norm and something businesses rely on heavily for publicity and future trade.  It’s no different for books and reviews can make a huge difference to future sales, especially for Indie Authors.

If your book garners 20-25 reviews, regardless of how many stars awarded, Amazon will highlight the novel under the ‘Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought and You might also like’ section on a page.  If your book receives more than 50 reviews, Amazon will include the title in their newsletter and increase its visibility on the site with spotlights, which means it will reach more potential readers.

Obviously, reviews are paramount to your book’s future success.  But how do you encourage readers to write reviews without resorting to begging and losing any sense of dignity?!  Readers are under no obligation to leave a review and to be fair, they’ve already paid you the highest compliment of buying your book in the first place.  But I honestly believe that if readers knew how much of a difference their review could make in terms of potential revenue and ratings, I think they would be much more inclined to write one.  Particularly when it comes to Amazon, they make it extremely easy to leave a review with their ‘reminder’ email, asking you to rate the book.  These ratings are so important, because even when it comes to promoting your book with sites like Bookbub, they take your star rating into account.

At the end of my books, I leave a message asking the reader to consider leaving a review, but even readers who contact me personally to say they enjoyed my book are reluctant to write a review, as they don’t know what they’re expected to say.  If you scroll through the reviews on Amazon on Goodreads, you will find that a lot of reviews are written by professional book bloggers and are written in a standard format that includes the blurb and an in-depth critique of the novel.  However, that is not what author’s expect from readers.  A couple of lines saying why you liked the book (or didn’t like it), your favourite part and maybe a similar book that it reminded you of.  I am currently reading a book that I would describe as an ‘Entertaining read, very likeable characters and an interesting plot.  Fans of Nick Hornby would like this book.’  However, when I REALLY like a book, I go all out and write something more in depth.  It’s really up to the reader – if you’re really moved by a book, you want to shout from the rooftops about it.  But if it’s just okay or average, you might not bother.  That is where writers come in – we need to inform readers that every review counts, even the not so brilliant ones (I’ll live to regret that statement!)

The truth is that we all rely on reviews to some degree before hitting the ‘Buy’ button.  I always check out the reviews on Goodreads and Amazon before buying a book, just to get a feel for it and even if there are negative reviews, it can sometimes influence my decision to buy.  As an example, I recently bought and read an AMAZING book that I absolutely loved (you can see me gush about it here) and that was after I saw a negative review saying that it was a story about a girl who talks to squirrels.  Talking squirrels you say?  Count me in!  Obviously, the story was about so much more than that and it’s clear the reviewer hadn’t read the entire book.  But the point is that what turned her off (a little quirkieness) completely turned me on.  So you see, all reviews have their own funny way of influencing future readers.  Ultimately, I think most people make up their mind using a combination of the blurb, the cover and reviews, but it definitely makes a book look more appealing if there are more reviews beside it.

So I would really encourage you, the next time you finish reading a book to leave a short (or long) review.  Your feedback has a big impact on, not only the book’s future, but also the author’s career.  Writers and readers are so important to each other, as the author John Cheever once said:

“I can’t write without a reader. It’s precisely like a kiss—you can’t do it alone.”

The Mysterious Bakery On Rue de Paris (7) - Copy


The Mysterious Bakery On Rue De Paris on Amazon.


The Cross of Santiago-Amazon - Copy   The Cross Of Santiago on Amazon.


6 thoughts on “Dear Readers, Your Review Matters!

  1. You’re so right, sometimes I feel I haven’t fully finished a book until I’ve reviewed it. Kind of puts everything to bed for me.

    psst … What did the Psychologist say to the Squirrel? You’re one tough nut to crack!

    1. You’ve been reading my last review, haven’t you!?! That’s a lovely way to look at it and it’s true, writing a review gives you an opportunity to say how you felt about the book, which is a nice kind of closure.

  2. I agree with you. That is one of the main reasons I established a blog. However, beyond using Goodreads I refuse to use Amazon. (I dislike what Bezos does to publishing and believe his goal is to be the ONLY publisher left.) I stayed with Goodreads after Bezos bought it simply because I was already so entrenched in it, and I do love the interactions/accessibility it provides. I don’t know why so few people are willing to leave even a brief review of their reaction to a book. For me, it only makes sense to do so after spending hours ingesting a written work to record your own thoughts, even if only for your own reference! I should publish a post on this same issue…time…time is all I lack, not motivation, for either reading or blogging, just…time…as with most of us!!

    1. Hi Lynn, I’m the very same in that I have to get my thoughts down straight away (before I forget!) I guess it’s just habit – once you start writing reviews, it becomes part of the reading process. I think Goodreads is a great place to keep a record of your reading life (but I hear what you’re saying about everything slowly merging into one large corporation). Still, it’s the best platform I’ve seen to encourage readers to be more interactive with their book choices and really demonstrates how important reviews can be for a book.

  3. Pingback: Reviews: The Good, The Bad And The Ugly – Evie Gaughan

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s